Sunday, December 29, 2019

Masculinity


I've had something on my mind for quite a long time. I have had certain reservations about sharing for many reasons, but ultimately I felt like for my peace of mind I needed to write about it. 

I can't seem to stop thinking about the way masculinity is viewed in this society. The way men are expected to act or to be seen as manly. Men crying, liking fruity cocktails, liking musicals, wants to be on a dance team etc. are seen as girly. It is scoffed at and I can't tell you the amount of "man shaming" that occurs when someone talks about having a fruity drink or whatever it is. What also makes it worse is that gay men, like me, are given a "pass" or it is just seen as 'oh well he is gay so it's okay'. Which then beckons the question - am I less of a man because of these things?

I know a group of men that pride themselves on the fact that they will never watch The Greatest Showman. Like it makes them more of a man for not wanting to watch it. You should hear the way they talk about it. 

Up until just recently I didn't like musicals. I had completely convinced myself that they were boring, that they didn't have to sing the entire dialogue. I really believed I didn't like them even after coming out as gay. It wasn't until I watched The Greatest Showman and LOVED it that I realized what I had been doing subconsciously my entire life. I was looking for any type of an excuse for why I didn't like it. I couldn't like it because it wasn't manly. After falling in love with The Greatest Showman I decided I would start watching some classic musicals. For the very first time I watched Les Miserable, The Phantom of the Opera, I went to a play and watched Phantom at Hale Center Theater. I very much enjoyed watching them. And yet, how cliché of me, a gay man, to like musicals, right? 

I actually don't care if others joke around with me for being the cliché gay man. For liking fruity drinks or musicals. My concern is for other men that are around that might feel demasculinized by these comments because they too like these things.

I've seen videos where mothers are telling their sons to stop crying because boys don't cry. It was comforting the way others poured their sympathy for the boys in those videos, but the sad truth is it still happens way too often. 

The problem is that I see toxic masculinity all the time and all over the place. And to be completely honest I'm not innocent of this either. I recently caught myself telling a man to stop acting like a little girl, indicating he was anything but masculine. I caught myself the second I said it and I hated that I did say it. People might say "I'm only joking or I didn't mean it." But unfortunately these jokes really do impact how men see themselves. The way they subconsciously suppress their feelings or hide who they are because of it. My worry is that some might not realize that what they are saying diminishes ones sense of masculinity. 

My main reservation about posting this is I know people that will read this might be guilty of what I'm talking about. But I really am not posting this to call anyone out nor shame anyone. I do want to put a spotlight on the issue. I've admitted I have been just as guilty of this. So I want to hold myself accountable so I don't make comments like I made earlier. That way I don't contribute to the toxic masculinity that is so rampant all around us.

4 comments:

  1. I'm so sorry that you have had this experience. I feel that musicals are amazing. My husband and I really enjoy them. I also feel that people who automatically label a certain genre of music or movie, are naive. There are good and bad examples in all genres.

    Our family went to Hugh Jackman's concert when he was in town and he said then movies come out, they look at big cities to see how a movie is doing (ie NYC, LA etc.) but you know where was listed 3rd as far as movie popularity? Salt Lake City

    If we all thought a little more and slowed our comments down a bit, I feel there would be a little bit less hurt feelings. This is my goal for this year. I find myself saying things and after thinking about what was said and feeling stupid, or just wondering why I felt the need to say it.

    Thank you for sharing and I look forward to reading your blog.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Really? SLC is the 3rd as far as movie popularity? That's cool. Ya, I really like musicals and am excited to continue to watch more.

      I agree if we could all be more thoughtful before speaking we would really hurt less feelings.

      I don't write a lot, but if you're interested in reading some of my past posts you will have to let me know what you think.

      Delete
  2. Being a transman, I have definately felt the stifling nature our culture puts on masculinity. Before I transitioned, I was allowed to wear both men and women's clothing and no one batted an eye. I could order a beer or a cocktail and no one cared. I could cry when ever I felt the need. Even though coming out as a man should make me feel more free, because I'm now presenting as I've always felt I was on the inside, I feel more trapped by the constraints of being a man in our culture. As a woman, I could do feminine or masculine things but as a man, I feel forced to comply with only what is seen as masculine or others will think I'm less of a man, which I already feel being a transman. I would love to live in a world where people can just be who they are, male, female or nonbinary, express themselves however they want, masculine or feminine or some where in between and be accepted as is.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Wow, thanks for reading and for sharing from your perspective. It is sad, but true the way our society views masculinity. If only we all could express ourselves the way we want without the worry of being mocked or thought off less than because of it. Again thanks for commenting

      Delete